I understand the traditional aesthetic the hotel was aiming for, however the lack of maintenance and updating for comfort purposes made us want to go home - a hotel experience should feel like the other way round where you would like to stay longer.
The windows were still single pane, therefore the noise of people in the streets and the bars/restaurants emptying bottles after midnight was very clear to hear, amongst many other noises both inside and outside. Other hotels we stayed in at Edinburgh included additional panes to prevent this.
The bed and carpet appeared very worn down - the floor appeared dirty, and the base of the carpet was visible in some areas which is the last thing you’d want to stand on after a shower when you leave to get changed.
The bed was very springy and dipped in the middle which made for an uncomfortable nights sleep when sharing the bed.
The location however was excellent - everything was super convenient with a 15min walk away to certain locations at most.
I rarely complain about services - but paying over £400 for a room, to have a bad experience based on the above and wanting to leave, left me feeling disappointed.