Book Shelter Island hotels

We were very disappointed after we got home and saw our card was charged about $40. When I called I was told it was a hotel tax. When I book through Expedia I assume it’s a One stop shop to book trips and pay what I owe at time of booking, not have a surprise charge for something made up. You work hard to try and afford a trip and then get charged more money. Expedia contacted them to try and remedy and they said to agent, it was for WiFi, CHAIRS, TOWELS! What does that even mean?! We were there one night in May, no chairs were used or towels, we didn’t even use the shower! Needless to say, that was our last time at this place. BEWARE OF EXTRA weird charges.

Cute place great views would go back in the summer

Great for dogs - huge fenced yard

We made our reservation paid the bill we got to the hotel they told us you have to pay $29 a night to park your car in the hotel parking lot. WE WERE NEVER INFORMED OF THIS!! I have my reservation to prove it!!!

Stellar staff who made us feel most welcome. Loved the diversity of the team. Unforgettable scenery and experiences. We will definitely come back!

The problem is that you can hear everything in all of the rooms above and to the right and left of you. I had a room on the first floor. I could hear every door shut, every step taken above me, and and most every conversation going on around me. It's a cute little place not far from the town center and ocean, however, if you need to have a sound sleep, be aware that it won't happen.